Since we never seem to properly track these things, and we have a website, I’ve decided to make a weekly post tracking our predictions and who’s ahead in the score: me or John. More interestingly, we’re giving you all a chance to play along. Each week, we’ll post a poll to see who our listeners is going home in that week’s episode (no spoilers!). At the end of the season, we’ll see who was best at this.

Apparently, none of us were creative enough in our thinking to predict that the blue tribe would throw a challenge to get rid of Joe Joaquin, thereby saving John’s all-time favourite Survivor. Not even John, in all his crazy thoughts of how to save Shirin came up with that one (or even the idea that they’d just plain lose). Not surprising though, since John and I have been absolute trash in the prediction department this season (the one John got right was only when he changed it at the last minute so as to not have the same prediction as me). One excuse: we used to predict one person per tribe to offset the uncertainty of who would win the random challenges they throw at contestants. But even there, I think that only would have led John and I to join you all in predicting Nina in episode three.

Here’s hoping we do better post-merge. So who do you think will be the first victim of the individual game?